Dr. Sean Tobin Subscribe

January 19, 2026

When Obedience Disappoints

Why Jesus Refused to Become Who People Needed Him to Be

“The fear of man lays a snare, but whoever trusts in the Lord is safe.”
— Proverbs 29:25

We often assume that following God will mainly provoke opposition from enemies.
What we are far less prepared for is how often it disappoints the people we love most.

Jesus was not only criticized by religious leaders and skeptics. He was questioned, misunderstood, and implicitly accused of absence or neglect by His friends—by people who trusted Him, followed Him, and believed in Him.

And He did not resolve that disappointment by becoming who they expected Him to be.

“If You Had Been Here…” — Disappointment as a Cry of Love

In the Gospel of John, Jesus receives word that His close friend Lazarus is dying. He delays. When He finally arrives, Lazarus has already been dead for four days.

Both sisters—Mary and Martha—say the same thing to Him:

“Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died.”
— John 11:21, 32

This is not theology.
It is grief speaking through disappointment.

In human language, it sounds like:

Jesus does not correct them.
He does not explain His timing.
He does not say, “You’ll understand later.”

He weeps.

And then—on the Father’s timing, not theirs—He acts.

Love is present.
But it is not reactive.

When Calm Feels Like Neglect

Another familiar scene: the disciples are in a boat, caught in a violent storm. Jesus is asleep.

They wake Him and cry out:

“Teacher, do you not care that we are perishing?”
— Mark 4:38

This is not about the storm.
It is about interpretation.

If you cared, you wouldn’t be this calm.

Here is a difficult truth: peace in a crisis often feels like abandonment to people who are afraid.

Jesus calms the storm—but not before revealing something deeper. Their fear had already formed a conclusion about who He was.

Circumstances became the lens through which they interpreted His character.

We still do this.

Broken Promises or Unexamined Expectations?

Much of our disappointment—both with God and with one another—does not come from broken promises, but from unexamined expectations we quietly attach to those promises.

The apostles believed in the Messiah.
They trusted Scripture.
They followed Jesus faithfully.

And yet, they expected a military savior—a king who would overthrow Rome, restore Israel, and establish visible power.

Even after the Resurrection, they ask Him:

“Lord, will you at this time restore the kingdom to Israel?”
— Acts 1:6

Their disappointment was not rooted in unbelief.
It was rooted in assuming they understood how God would fulfill what He had promised.

When expectations harden into certainties, they become pressure:

Holding someone to their word can easily slide into demanding they fulfill it according to our understanding of what it should mean.

That is where disappointment turns into accusation.

The Ancient Reflex: Blame Instead of Mystery

When suffering confuses us, we often reach for the specific safety and certainty of blame.

In John 9, the disciples see a man born blind and immediately ask Jesus:

“Who sinned, this man or his parents?”
— John 9:2

When in doubt, we assume:

Jesus rejects the framing entirely.

He does not locate the cause in personal failure.
He reframes suffering as field, not verdict:

“This happened so that the works of God might be revealed in him.”

Not explained.
Not justified.
Revealed.

The Fear of Man and the Tyranny of “Should”

Scripture says plainly:

“The fear of man lays a snare.”
— Proverbs 29:25

A snare is subtle. Invisible.
Most of us grow up inside it without realizing it.

Fear of man does not just look like caring what people think. It becomes:

We place “shoulds” on others to regulate our own fear:

Sometimes those statements are true.
Often, they are attempts to manage uncertainty.

Jesus Loved Without Becoming the Source of Everyone’s Comfort

Jesus loved deeply. He wept. He healed. He fed the hungry.

But He never positioned Himself as the emotional regulator of adults.

He remained oriented toward the Father:

“The Son can do nothing by himself; he can do only what he sees his Father doing.”
— John 5:19

This orientation scandalizes people.

Because it means:

The Cross itself looked like abandonment—until Resurrection revealed it as obedience.

The Good Samaritan and the Divided Heart

Jesus tells a story of a man beaten and left for dead on the road. Religious leaders pass by on the other side. A Samaritan stops, binds his wounds, and carries him to safety.

What we often miss is this:
others are still walking past while the Samaritan is loving.

Unless they repent, the Samaritan’s compassion becomes an indictment—not because he judges them, but because love reveals where hearts are divided.

Real love does that.

Letting Go of Who We Think We Are

Saint Paul writes:

“For you have died, and your life is hidden with Christ in God.”
— Colossians 3:3

A hidden life looks irresponsible to people who need visibility.
A hidden obedience looks careless to people who need control.

But this is the cost of freedom.

“It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me.”
— Galatians 2:20

That sentence is not poetic.
It is a death—to reputation, to self-definition, to the illusion that being loved means being understood.

If we are not willing to let go of who we think we are—or who we think others should be—we will never become who we were made to be.

A Quiet Ending

Jesus did not manage everyone’s disappointment.
He entrusted Himself to the Father.

Some people waited for Resurrection.
Many did not.

That is the risk of love.
That is the cost of freedom.
That is the narrow road of trust.

And it is still the way.

This essay first appeared on The Inner Exodus. Get the next one in your inbox:

Subscribe free